What you consider as the right birth time - Contd

Ms Shyamala Subramaniam has posted the following comment.

Thank You madam for your comments.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Dear Sir
Hearty Congratulations on your attaining Postgraduation in Astrology. In fact we have to thank your father for giving us a wonderful teacher in your form by planting his gene in you.

well for the answer to the question raised by you:
1. Point 1,2,and 3 are not correct as any part of the body can appear at the cervix leading to surgery too.
2. Secondly as the child has to have a breath to be considered as 'live born', point 8 and 9 are also not appropriate as per medical terms.
3. placenta can break even before a child starts its own life individually.
4. The real living on its own starts only when it breathes on its own. In the womb also it is born and living but on the mother's oxygen.
5. generally the coincidence of a child breathing and the cutting of umbilical cord happens together,but in some cases the cord is severed and the child has to be slapped to instill the breathing conditions.if the latter is not done the child does not see the light of the world.
6. in some cases due to some reasons the umbilical cord is severed off after a few minutes. in such cases if the child has started its own breathing then the time of first breath counts,if not the time of the cutting of umbilical cord will count. What was done on medical grounds will have to be revealed by doctors
So both points like the 'first breath or cutting off umbilical cord' play a role answer for this question.
The above answers are based on my biology knowledge(I am a biologist)
looking forward eagerly to know your views and the correct answer
Regards
Shyamala